Goodwill Shift Supervisor reviews

2.2

16% would recommend to a friend

(41 total reviews)

Catherine Meloy

7% approve of CEO

7% positive business outlook

Shift Supervisor employees have rated Goodwill with 2.2 out of 5 stars, based on 41 company reviews on Glassdoor. This indicates that most Shift Supervisor professionals have an average working experience there. Goodwill is rated 41% below average by Shift Supervisor professionals compared to other employers within the Non-profit and NGO industry (3.7 stars).

Reviews by job title

41 reviews
3.0
28 Apr 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

I enjoyed my customer service work - helping people as a part of a larger mission to help the community. I found it rewarding to advance to supervisor and pick up new skills and responsibilities such as safety auditing and supply management. And of course it was always interesting to sort all the interesting and unique donated goods.

Cons

A change in management over the past year+ has been very difficult for me. I found my work more heavily scrutinized and criticized in ways that felt unclear and unfair. The new manager had a clear bias towards certain employees, gossiped openly and loudly and often with explicit HIPAA violations, and made it literally impossible for me to keep track of inventory supplies as a part of my responsibilities. Communication between management and associates - and even between management and supervisors is very poor. Workplace culture has seemed to shift from being very flexible and people-oriented to more stringent on policy and focused on revenue. Trust in upper management is strained. Day to day if you stick to your task and focus on production, you'll probably do well. But for me it isn't what it used to be.

1.0
20 Feb 2026

Toxic

Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Ability to have first dibs on most donations.

Cons

The work load and expectations can be excessive at times.

2.0
31 Jan 2026

Low pay for supervisors

Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

None. The pay was 12.50 and I had access to the safe and security system.

Cons

Low pay. No work life balance, horrible management.

Viewing 1 - 3 of 41 Reviews

Glassdoor has 9,717 Goodwill reviews submitted anonymously by Goodwill employees. Read employee reviews and ratings on Glassdoor to decide if Goodwill is right for you.