employer cover photo
employer logo
employer logo

Builders Mutual Insurance

Is this your company?

It's okay...not the best but not the worst either - Anonymous employee Builders Mutual Insurance Employee Review

3.0
31 Jul 2015
Anonymous employee
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Work life balance is pretty good. You can make up 4 hours in a week, if you have a` doctor appointment, sick kid, or any other thing going. This is great and keeps you from having to take vacation for every little thing. Builders prides itself on the BMIC culture and this means you'll get to partake in charity events, ice cream socials, and other company functions. Vacation starts at about 17 days your first year. They match 5% 401k and your insurance can be as low as 20 bucks. There is flex-time. The people are super nice!

Cons

While there is flex-time, not in the Claims Dept. Why you ask?? Beyond me. We were told because core hours are 8-5 and everyone should be in the office at this time. I think they feel everyone would want to come in early and leave early. That's not the case. Some people like early, some people like to sleep in longer. The office can be real "cliqu-ish". Those that are apart of the clique get what they want, other's do not. If you have worked here for years, you are held in high regard even if your performance is lackluster. Suggestions aren't taken into account by management. The system for claims is absolutely horrible and they refuse to update it. The pay is below standard for claims employees in other areas.

Explore other reviews about Builders Mutual Insurance

5.0
21 Aug 2025
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Work life balance Manageable case load

Cons

None that I can think of

2.0
28 May 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Builders Mutual seemed like a generally decent company with good people. Overall, it may be a good fit for someone who prefers a stable, traditional corporate environment.

Cons

The technology culture felt somewhat old-school and slow to modernize. The company appeared uneven in its adoption of newer tools like AI and automation, and the hybrid work policy created frustration because some employees were required to come into the office while others were allowed to remain fully remote. It may feel limiting for someone looking for a more modern, flexible, and technology-forward workplace.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All