Shift Lead position is a dead end - Shift Lead Instacart Employee Review

1.0
26 Sept 2017
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Autonomy in store means you can come up with and execute your own improvement plans. Occasional meetings with Ops team allows you to sync up and feel more like part of the Instacart family. Comfortable work environment on the ground in grocery stores - relaxed dress code means (instacart) tshirt, jeans, and sneakers. Assignment to one or two primary stores fosters a healthy working relationship with in-store management.

Cons

Low pay compared to responsibilities expected; responsibilities and formal expectations make you feel like you should be a full fledged member of the ops team, but pay, benefits, and lack of vacation do not match. Communication between ops team and Shift Leads is very obfuscated - it's hard to get a consistent idea of what goals and expectations the ops team has for you/your store and to understand what's going on for the company as a whole. Frequently asked to implement half baked improvement strategies without giving shift leads any voice in the creation of these strategies. Failure of said strategies is heaped only on shift leads. No room to grow - there are no positions above shift lead that aren't part of the Instacart operations office team. While working for the company, these positions rarely open up and when they do the lack of professional development opportunities become very obvious and make it very difficult to make the cut. Newer ideas and product feedback is frequently received with the equivalent of a pat on the head. These ideas rarely make it high enough on the food chain to even be considered for implementation.

Explore other reviews about Instacart

5.0
29 Mar 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Great gig that can be done on flexible hours.

Cons

Gas prices having been go up.

2.0
21 Jun 2026
Recommend
CEO approval
Business outlook

Pros

Fun going out and talking to people. You will interact with people everyday. You control how much you get paid. Lots of flexibility in the time between accepting an order and traveling to the store and beginning to shop. It isn't pedal to the metal to get to the store like DoorDash is. You can also cancel batches after accepting as long as you keep your rate under 15%. This is different from DoorDash where your rankings will suffer if g.t. 2% cancellation rate.

Cons

There's a learning curve and it takes a while to learn each chain of stores' items. Once you become proficient at one store, the algorithm will lowball your offers relative to other less-experienced Instacart shoppers. Overall, Instacart shoppers likely get paid similar or less than the store's regular employees.

See reviews by: Helpful|Rating|Date|All